Name: Toni Payne
Nationality: Nigeria
Date of Birth: April 22, 1995
Position: Attacker
Current club: Everton
Women's Super League clubs played for: Everton

Toni Payne is an attacker at Everton who has taken part in the vast majority of the club's Women's Super League matches in 2025/2026, making 15 appearances overall and playing 833 minutes. She has been selected in the starting XI in 10 of these appearances across their 18 fixtures and been used as a substitute on five occasions.

The last time that Payne featured in the league came on March 21 for Everton against Manchester United; a game that she played 63 minutes in during a 2-1 defeat. This season the attacker has registered two Women's Super League assists - tied for the most for her side. She has been shown one yellow card.

Everton play host to Liverpool on March 28 the next time the team are in Women's Super League action.

Payne played 22 Women's Super League games last season for Everton, scored one goal and provided five assists.

Payne joined Everton in July 2024 from Sevilla, for whom she made 169 league appearances in total, scoring 30 goals and providing 20 assists.